Even|RB More|JJR "|'' Proving|NNP Rape|NNP "|'' 
Chatterbox|NNP feels|VBZ that|IN the|DT Wall|NNP Street|NNP Journal|NNP editorial|NN page|NN 's|POS coverage|NN of|IN Juanita|NNP Broaddrick|NNP 's|POS rape|NN charges|NNS against|IN Bill|NNP Clinton|NNP (|( see|VB "|'' Proving|NNP Rape|NNP ,|, "|'' "|'' More|JJR Proving|NNP Rape|NNP ,|, "|'' as|RB well|RB as|IN Michael|NNP Kinsley|NNP 's|POS "|'' Readme|NNP "|'' column|NN in|IN the|DT current|JJ issue|NN )|) cries|VBZ out|IN for|IN the|DT introduction|NN of|IN the|DT Scientific|NNP Method|NNP into|IN the|DT usually|RB mushy|JJ business|NN of|IN assessing|VBG press|NN responsibility|NN .|. 
With|IN that|DT in|IN mind|NN ,|, Chatterbox|NNP hereby|NN inaugurates|NNS the|DT Intellectual|NNP Dishonesty|NN (|( henceforth|NN to|TO be|VB known|VBN as|IN the|DT Indis|NNP )|) Index|NN .|. 
Here|RB 's|POS how|WRB it|PRP works|VBZ :|: 
Publications|NNP that|WDT refuse|VBP to|TO acknowledge|VB (|( even|RB if|IN to|TO refute|VB the|DT importance|NN of|IN )|) highly|RB significant|JJ but|CC inconvenient|JJ facts|NNS in|IN their|PRP$ news|NN or|CC opinion|NN coverage|NN of|IN controversial|JJ events|NNS will|MD score|NN one|CD point|NN for|IN the|DT initial|JJ offense|NN .|. 
They|PRP will|MD then|RB score|NN one|CD point|NN for|IN every|DT subsequent|JJ issue|NN or|CC broadcast|NN or|CC Internet|NN posting|VBG after|IN the|DT first|JJ offense|NN is|VBZ noted|VBN by|IN Chatterbox|NNP if|IN they|PRP continue|VBP not|RB to|TO report|NN said|VBD inconvenient|JJ fact--and|JJ an|DT additional|JJ two|CD points|NNS on|IN days|NNS when|WRB the|DT news|NN organization|NN runs|VBZ a|DT follow-up|JJ without|IN making|VBG note|NN of|IN said|VBD inconvenient|JJ fact|NN .|. 
Publications|NNP receiving|VBG a|DT score|NN of|IN 10|CD will|MD be|VB inducted|JJ into|IN the|DT Indis|NNP Hall|NNP of|IN Fame|NNP .|. 
Publications|NNP that|WDT get|VBP all|PDT the|DT way|NN up|IN to|TO 20|CD will|MD be|VB faxed|VBD a|DT likeness|NN of|IN Joseph|NNP Stalin|NNP .|. 
(|( Chatterbox|NNP would|MD prefer|VB not|RB to|TO invoke|VB the|DT phrase|NN "|'' intellectual|JJ dishonesty|NN ,|, "|'' because|IN it|PRP 's|VBZ pompous|JJ and|CC falsely|RB suggests|VBZ that|IN only|JJ intellectuals|NNS can|MD be|VB intellectually|RB dishonest|JJ .|. 
But|CC Chatterbox|NNP does|VBZ n't|RB know|VB any|DT other|JJ easily|RB understandable|JJ phrase|NN that|WDT describes|VBZ this|DT particular|JJ kind|NN of|IN offense|NN .|. )|) 

For|IN the|DT purposes|NNS of|IN this|DT survey|NN ,|, the|DT Wall|NNP Street|NNP Journal|NNP will|MD be|VB counted|VBN as|IN a|DT separate|JJ and|CC distinct|JJ publication|NN from|IN the|DT Journal|NNP 's|POS editorial|NN page|NN ,|, because|RB ,|, in|IN essence|NN ,|, it|PRP is|VBZ .|. 

The|DT Journal|NNP editorial|NN page|NN continues|VBZ not|RB to|TO acknowledge|VB that|IN Norma|NNP Kelsey|NNP ,|, the|DT friend|NN and|CC employee|NN to|TO Juanita|NNP Broaddrick|NNP who|WP is|VBZ one|CD of|IN two|CD people|NNS partially|RB corroborating|VBG Broaddrick|NNP 's|POS rape|NN accusation|NN ,|, is|VBZ the|DT daughter|NN of|IN a|DT man|NN whose|WP$ murderer|NN was|VBD pardoned|VBD by|IN Gov.|NN Bill|NNP Clinton|NNP .|. 
(|( A|DT responsible|JJ account|NN of|IN the|DT whole|JJ controversy|NN in|IN today|NN 's|POS New|NNP York|NNP Times|NNP reports|NNS that|IN Kelsey|NNP says|VBZ the|DT pardon|NN had|VBD nothing|NN to|TO do|VB with|IN her|PRP$ corroboration|NN .|. )|) 
The|DT Journal|NNP editorial|NN page|NN gets|VBZ one|CD point|NN for|IN failing|VBG to|TO note|VB the|DT pardon|NN in|IN its|PRP$ initial|JJ Op-|NNP Ed|NNP by|IN Dorothy|NNP Rabinowitz|NNP on|IN Feb|NNP .|. 19|CD .|. 
Because|IN it|PRP has|VBZ published|VBN three|CD times|NNS since|IN the|DT initial|JJ omission|NN ,|, it|PRP scores|NNS an|DT additional|JJ three|CD points|NNS .|. 
And|CC because|IN it|PRP published|VBD an|DT editorial|JJ Feb|NNP .|. 22|CD taunting|NN the|DT rest|NN of|IN the|DT press|NN for|IN not|RB following|VBG it|PRP on|IN the|DT story--and|JJ still|RB did|VBD n't|RB mention|VB the|DT pardon--it|JJ scores|NNS an|DT extra|JJ two|CD points|NNS .|. 
That|DT comes|VBZ to|TO a|DT total|NN of|IN six|CD .|. 
Chatterbox|NNP feels|VBZ certain|JJ that|IN the|DT Journal|NNP editorial|NN page|NN will|MD provide|VB some|DT follow-up|JJ tomorrow|NN to|TO tonight|NN 's|POS NBC|NNP broadcast|NN of|IN its|PRP$ own|JJ Broaddrick|NNP interview|NN ,|, which|WDT means|VBZ that|IN if|IN the|DT Journal|NNP editorial|NN page|NN continues|VBZ to|TO take|VB no|DT action|NN it|PRP will|MD be|VB in|IN the|DT Indis|NNP Hall|NNP of|IN Fame|NNP by|IN Monday|NNP at|IN the|DT latest|JJS !|. 

Chatterbox|NNP considered|VBD but|CC rejected|VBN the|DT idea|NN of|IN awarding|VBG Rabinowitz|NNP bonus|NN points|NNS for|IN having|VBG "|'' eventually|RB convinced|VBN "|'' Broaddrick|NNP to|TO grant|VB an|DT interview|NN to|TO the|DT New|NNP York|NNP Times|NNP (|( as|IN the|DT Times|NNP reports|NNS in|IN today|NN 's|POS story|NN )|) .|. 
But|CC the|DT Scientific|NNP Method|NNP does|VBZ not|RB permit|VB any|DT tinkering|NN with|IN the|DT Indis|NNP Index|NNP 's|POS scoring|VBG procedures|NNS .|. 
And|CC besides|IN ,|, Rabinowitz|NNP 's|POS efforts|NNS on|IN the|DT Times|NNP '|POS behalf|NN were|VBD n't|RB really|RB unethical|JJ ,|, just|RB puzzling|JJ ,|, given|VBN the|DT two|CD newspapers|NNS '|POS intense|JJ rivalry|NN .|. 
When|WRB Chatterbox|NNP asked|VBD the|DT Journal|NNP 's|POS DC|NNP bureau|NN chief|NN ,|, Alan|NNP Murray|NNP ,|, who|WP exercised|VBD good|JJ judgment|NN in|IN not|RB breaking|VBG the|DT Broaddrick|NNP story|NN (|( and--full|JJ disclosure--|JJ is|VBZ Chatterbox|NNP 's|POS former|JJ boss|NN )|) ,|, to|TO comment|VB about|IN a|DT Journal|NNP employee|NN 's|POS feeding|NN sources|NNS to|TO the|DT Times|NNP ,|, he|PRP replied|VBD :|: "|'' I|PRP do|VBP n't|RB really|RB have|VB any|DT comment|NN on|IN what|WP the|DT edit|VB page|NN did|VBD .|. 
They|PRP do|VBP their|PRP$ thing|NN ,|, we|PRP do|VBP ours|PRP .|. "|'' 
Which|WDT is|VBZ what|WP Journal|NNP news|NN employees|NNS are|VBP instructed|VBN to|TO say|VB whenever|WRB the|DT editorial|NN page|NN causes|NNS them|PRP cringing|VBG embarrassment|NN .|. 

For|IN her|PRP$ part|NN ,|, Rabinowitz|NNP explains|VBZ to|TO Chatterbox|NNP that|IN her|PRP$ efforts|NNS on|IN behalf|NN of|IN the|DT Times|NNP were|VBD more|RBR indifferent|JJ than|IN the|DT Times|NNP made|VBD them|PRP sound|VBP .|. 
"|'' Ms.|NN Broaddrick|NNP told|VBD me|PRP Sunday|NNP that|IN a|DT Times|NNP reporter|NN had|VBD appeared|VBN at|IN the|DT house|NN in|IN the|DT a.m.|NN ,|, and|CC that|IN she|PRP had|VBD refused|VBN an|DT interview|NN ,|, "|'' Rabinowitz|NNP writes|VBZ in|IN an|DT e-mail|JJ message|NN .|. 
"|'' I|PRP asked|VBD her|PRP$ why|WRB she|PRP had|VBD decided|VBN to|TO talk|VB to|TO the|DT New|NNP York|NNP Post|NNP 's|POS Steve|NNP Dunleavy|NNP ,|, and|CC refused|VBD a|DT Times|NNP reporter|NN .|. 
She|PRP said|VBD Dunleavy|NNP caught|VBD her|PRP by|IN surprise|NN .|. 
She|PRP asked|VBD if|IN I|PRP thought|VBD it|PRP would|MD be|VB all|DT right|NN to|TO talk|VB to|TO the|DT Times|NNP reporter|NN .|. 
I|PRP told|VBD her|PRP$ it|PRP would|MD be--certainly|JJ as|IN all|DT right|NN as|IN talking|VBG to|TO Dunleavy|NNP .|. 
She|PRP said|VBD ,|, '|'' Well|RB ,|, I|PRP 'm|VBP sorry|JJ I|PRP did|VBD n't|RB .|. 
'|POS She|PRP said|VBD she|PRP would|MD if|IN he|PRP called|VBD again|RB .|. 
I|PRP passed|VBD this|DT on|IN to|TO [|NN Times|NNP reporter|NN ]|NN Felicity|NNP Barringer|NNP during|IN our|PRP$ second|JJ day|NN 's|POS interview|NN chat|VB .|. 
So--that|NNP 's|POS how|WRB it|PRP happens|VBZ that|IN in|IN the|DT New|NNP York|NNP Times|NNP piece|NN today|NN I|PRP 'm|VBP described--solemnly--as|JJ having|VBG '|POS eventually|RB convinced|VBN '|POS her|PRP to|TO repeat|VB the|DT story|NN to|TO the|DT New|NNP York|NNP Times|NNP .|. "|'' 

-|: -|: Timothy|NNP Noah|NNP 

